It seems as though Back to School (BTS) season gets pushed further and further forward and this year is no exception. My local stores already set up their back to school promo areas the first week of July. I am in no way complaining here, but just like seasonal holidays, we are losing the distinct boundaries between "summer break" and back to school. This BTS season is also bittersweet as it is the first time in four years I, myself, do not have to purchase anything for a new semester. Anyhow, you're not here for my emotional diatribe, you are here for a review. So let's have at it:
Unless you have been living under a rock, you know my favorite pencil is the neon Casemate (Which is now called Pen + Gear). I cannot say enough about this pencil-- it writes beautifully, is vibrantly colored, and is super cheap. In an earlier review, I had come to the conclusion that these Made in India pencils are factory seconds of Nataraj neons. There are two versions of the Pen + Gear neons: Made in India and Made in the Philippines. The ones made in the Philippines have a round barrel and write terribly-- do not buy. This year, however, I noticed a pack of hexagonal neons and became incredibly excited because there was an additional color in the dozen: purple. I flipped over the package and groaned-- Made in the Philippines. Something made me want to buy these though and for 97 cents I figured if they still sucked, it wouldn't matter too much. After sharpening and using one for a bit, I discovered something: they are no neon Casemates, but they aren't horrible either.
At first glance, there are some distinct differences in the fit and finish of the Made in Philippines version. First, the paint on the barrel is super glossy whereas the paint on the Made in India version is more of a matte finish. Also, while the Made in Philippines version feels about the same weight-wise, the wood used is much more dense (if that makes sense). It is a lighter wood that is very soft and a bit fuzzy after sharpening with certain sharpeners, so I suspect it is either basswood or ash. When dropping the pencil, there is no "pencil sound" like other pencils make and it doesn't bounce much. The ferrule, eraser, and imprint are identical to the Made in India version. Writing with the Made in Philippines pencil is a bit different than the India version. The Philippines pencil is a bit scratchier than the India pencil, but lays down the same dark lines as the India version. I am wondering if it is the wood that leaves me feeling as though it is scratchier than the Indian pencil and not the actual graphite itself. One other aspect of the Philippines pencil I noticed was the fact that it had a very strong smell after sharpening it. I am not sure where that smell would be coming from, but I suspect it is perhaps the way they treated the wood or the actual finish on the pencil. Either way, I don't like it. Luckily the smell fades after a while so it's not horrific. While I do not completely recommend these Made in Philippines hex neon pencils over the Made in India ones, they are not garbage as previously stated. The round Made in Philippines pencils *are* still junk and are to be avoided at all costs.